Well lets not throw in the towel just yet there`s still a lot of golf to still be played . I was looking at your stats and also your gear and for the most part the world wont come to an end because of either . ) But then I got to thinking the problem may be as simple as your putter . You use the Nike putter and if my memory serves right the nike putter is more of a ding putter and not an off ding putter .
So the problem is you are using the wrong putting style with your putter . Since they are gone now I cant see the specs of the putter to be sure . But Im pretty sure that the nike putter is not a miss ding putter . Check it against the Versa putters and compare the specs.If the nike has more precision than forgiveness then that would be the problem .
The forgiveness allows you to miss the ding to a certain point before changing the outcome of the shot . As a miss ding player I always get the clubs with the most forgiveness for just that reason . Clubs with high precision you have to be more on the ding and when you miss you pay for it because of the low level of forgiveness .
So you may just be using the wrong putting style and nothing more . The solution is one of 2 options .
Option 1 Change your putting style and become a ding putter .
Option 2 Upgrade your putter to a putter that is made for your style of putting .
Me personally I`ve had the top 3 Versa putters and all are great for miss ding putting . I love mine to death and it was well worth the cost when I bought it . Most will tell you that the Versa putters are the best in the pro shop hands down .
So there you go hopefully a solution to your problem and I hope that Im right . So off you go to check my theory and hope it helps you with your game . :-)