Forums

MATCHPLAY COMP

• virtualreality 122 Posts

  Thu, Mar 10 2016 6:09 PM

  i am in

• MYTHofPANDORA 53 Posts

  Thu, Mar 10 2016 7:55 PM

   I will like 2 play

• ScarletBegonias 583 Posts

  Fri, Mar 11 2016 12:32 AM

  Count me in Paul if there is still room

  Neil

• binkybaxter1 1,556 Posts

  Fri, Mar 11 2016 1:02 AM

  gordon0762

  iainmclean

  scarletbegonias

  binkybaxter1

• PAULFINN52 3,172 Posts

  Fri, Mar 11 2016 2:59 AM

  MrQueez:

  PAULFINN52:

  i will make the draw and you could be playing any tier,i wont match up

  as i say its early days days but please give me your thought on it

  How about this.

  Champ vs TL 2 holes 

  Champ vs Legend 3 holes

  Champ vs TM 4 holes

  Champ vs Master 5 holes

  TL vs Legend 2 holes

  TL vs TM 3 holes

  TL vs Master 4 holes

  Legend vs TM 2 holes

  Legend vs Master 3 holes

  TM vs Master 2 holes

   

  that looks okay mate any other ideas out there for handicaps and get your names down lets get this comp filled

  paul

   

• 1,866 Posts

  Fri, Mar 11 2016 3:24 AM

  PAULFINN52:

  MrQueez:

  PAULFINN52:

  i will make the draw and you could be playing any tier,i wont match up

  as i say its early days days but please give me your thought on it

  How about this.

  Champ vs TL 2 holes 

  Champ vs Legend 3 holes

  Champ vs TM 4 holes

  Champ vs Master 5 holes

  TL vs Legend 2 holes

  TL vs TM 3 holes

  TL vs Master 4 holes

  Legend vs TM 2 holes

  Legend vs Master 3 holes

  TM vs Master 2 holes

   

  that looks okay mate any other ideas out there for handicaps and get your names down lets get this comp filled

  paul

   

  These looks fine, although I'd prefer them to be 1 hole only between each tier. 5 holes is a huge advantage on some courses. It would be very difficult to beat a half decent Master, playing from shorter tees on St. Andrews, for example.

   

  And I'm definitely in ;-)

   

• 478 Posts

  Fri, Mar 11 2016 3:58 AM

  I have a question: Can handicaps be set up when creating the game? If not, this concept is not applicable. What if we say that a M has an advantage of 6 holes vs. a Champ, and the Champ wins after 14 holes with 5up? Has he won the handicapped match or not? He will probably win another hole or two, but who knows?

  Or do we just say that a Champ has to win with at least 5up to win the match?

• 1,866 Posts

  Fri, Mar 11 2016 5:01 AM

  Tasor:

  I have a question: Can handicaps be set up when creating the game? If not, this concept is not applicable. What if we say that a M has an advantage of 6 holes vs. a Champ, and the Champ wins after 14 holes with 5up? Has he won the handicapped match or not? He will probably win another hole or two, but who knows?

  Or do we just say that a Champ has to with with at least 5up to win the match?

  Greetings, oh divine one ;-)

  It works like this, when someone has a 6 handicap, it means you're required to concede 6 holes to him. It's predetermined by the tourney organiser, which holes these are. Then you effectively need to win by at least 6 up (to force extra holes) over the remaining 12 holes you actually get to play.

  That's why I'm in favour of lesser handicaps ;-)

   

• 478 Posts

  Fri, Mar 11 2016 5:17 AM

  mkrizan86:

  Greetings, oh divine one ;-)

  LOL - hello ;-)

  mkrizan86:

  It works like this, when someone has a 6 handicap, it means you're required to concede 6 holes to him. It's predetermined by the tourney organiser, which holes these are. Then you effectively need to win by at least 6 up (to force extra holes) over the remaining 12 holes you actually get to play.

  That's why I'm in favour of lesser handicaps ;-)

  Thanks for the explanation, good to know! Then there is a huge difference between 5, 6 and 7. Winning 5 holes out of 13 should be possible, but winning 7 out of 11 is extremely hard and impossible without the "help" of the opponent. I think any handicap above 6 is too high.

• 1,866 Posts

  Fri, Mar 11 2016 5:19 AM

  Tasor:

  I think any handicap above 6 is too high.

  Make that 4 for my earthly abilities ;-)