Please add me to the list of people who HATE the autocaddy feature. I can't think of a single good reason to have it but I can sure think of far too many times when it has cost me strokes, and games. Just force me to select a club and swing type for the situation the way I have to do on every shot in the real world. I don't want to have to second guess a "caddy" who doesn't seem to have ever played golf.
Yes, I'm aware it's my responsibility to verify it's what I want but as mentioned above, you just don't remember to do that on every single shot. It especially kills me on wedge shots where it ALWAYS, without fail, chooses a totally impractical club and shot type, usually not even set for the right distance if you actually catch that it's set up that way.
This alone is enough to alienate me from the game as the happiest day in my WGT career was the day they gave us the Opt Out before.